The Honda Element. It’s a vehicle that evokes strong opinions. Some see it as the ultimate utility vehicle, a boxy, go-anywhere, do-anything machine. Others find its styling polarizing and question its practicality for everyday life. But is it genuinely a good vehicle? To answer that, we'll dive deep into the Element's strengths, weaknesses, and common complaints to help you decide if it's the right choice for you.
The Element's Allure: What Makes it So Popular?
The Honda Element's popularity stems from its unique blend of practicality and durability. It's not just about its distinctive boxy shape; it's about the features that make it incredibly versatile.
- Spacious Interior: The Element boasts a surprisingly roomy cabin, easily accommodating four adults comfortably. The tall roofline provides ample headroom, and the rear seats can be folded flat or even removed entirely, creating a cavernous cargo area.
- Easy-Clean Interior: This is perhaps the Element's defining feature. With its urethane-coated flooring and water-resistant seats, the Element is designed to withstand dirt, mud, and spills. It's perfect for outdoor enthusiasts, pet owners, and anyone who needs a vehicle that can handle a little mess.
- Rear Hinged Doors (Clamshell Doors): The rear-hinged doors, often referred to as "suicide doors," provide wide access to the rear seats and cargo area. While they require the front doors to be open, they make loading and unloading bulky items a breeze.
- Honda Reliability: Like many Honda vehicles, the Element is known for its reliability and longevity. With proper maintenance, these vehicles can easily rack up hundreds of thousands of miles.
- Affordable Used Car Option: Because production ceased in 2011, Elements are only available on the used market. This makes it an affordable and economical choice for those looking for a dependable and versatile vehicle.
Decoding the Criticisms: What are the Common Element Complaints?
Despite its popularity, the Honda Element isn't without its flaws. Understanding these common complaints is crucial before making a purchase.
Fuel Economy Concerns:
- Boxy Shape = Poor Aerodynamics: The Element's boxy design is a double-edged sword. While it maximizes interior space, it also creates significant wind resistance, negatively impacting fuel economy. Expect to get around 20-22 mpg in the city and 24-25 mpg on the highway, which isn't stellar compared to other small SUVs.
- Four-Wheel Drive Penalty: The available four-wheel-drive system adds weight and complexity, further reducing fuel economy. If you don't need four-wheel drive, opting for the front-wheel-drive model will save you some money at the pump.
Ride Quality and Handling:
- Truck-Like Ride: The Element's suspension is tuned for durability and cargo-carrying capacity, which can result in a somewhat stiff and bouncy ride, especially on rough roads.
- Wind Noise: The boxy shape and large windows contribute to noticeable wind noise at highway speeds. This can be a nuisance on long trips.
- Handling is Not Sporty: The Element is not designed for spirited driving. Its high center of gravity and soft suspension make it prone to body roll in corners.
Interior and Features:
- Basic Interior: While the easy-clean interior is a major selling point, some find it aesthetically unappealing. The hard plastic surfaces and simple design lack the refinement of more modern SUVs.
- Limited Features (Especially in Early Models): Early Element models lacked some features that are now considered standard, such as power windows and locks in the base trim.
- Rear Door Quirks: While the clamshell doors provide excellent access, they can be inconvenient in tight parking spaces, as you need to open the front doors to open the rear doors.
Maintenance and Repair:
- Specific Parts Availability: While most Honda parts are readily available, some Element-specific parts, such as body panels and interior trim pieces, can be harder to find and more expensive.
- Potential for Rust: Like many older vehicles, the Element is susceptible to rust, particularly in areas with harsh winters. Inspect the undercarriage and body panels for signs of corrosion before purchasing.
Diving Deeper: Common Issues and How to Spot Them
Beyond the general complaints, certain issues are more prevalent in Honda Elements. Knowing what to look for can save you from costly repairs down the road.
- Catalytic Converter Failure: This is a common issue in older Elements. Symptoms include a check engine light, reduced fuel economy, and a sulfur-like smell.
- Oxygen Sensor Issues: Faulty oxygen sensors can also trigger the check engine light and affect fuel economy.
- Valve Adjustments: Honda engines require periodic valve adjustments. Neglecting this maintenance can lead to engine damage.
- Rear Differential Issues (4WD Models): The rear differential in four-wheel-drive Elements can be prone to wear and tear. Listen for unusual noises from the rear of the vehicle, especially when turning.
- AC Compressor Failure: The AC compressor is a common failure point, especially in hot climates.
How to Spot These Issues:
- Thorough Inspection: Before buying an Element, have it inspected by a qualified mechanic. They can identify potential problems that you might miss.
- Check Engine Light: Pay close attention to the check engine light. If it's illuminated, have the code scanned to determine the cause.
- Test Drive: Take the Element for a thorough test drive, paying attention to how it handles, accelerates, and brakes. Listen for any unusual noises.
- Maintenance Records: Review the vehicle's maintenance records to see if it has been properly maintained.
- Rust Inspection: Carefully inspect the undercarriage, body panels, and door jambs for signs of rust.
The Element and Its Competitors: How Does It Stack Up?
The Honda Element carved out a unique niche in the automotive market, but it did have some competitors. Understanding how it compares to these alternatives can help you make a more informed decision.
- Toyota RAV4: The RAV4 is a more conventional SUV that offers better fuel economy and a more refined interior. However, it lacks the Element's easy-clean interior and unique cargo-carrying capabilities.
- Subaru Forester: The Forester is another popular SUV with standard all-wheel drive. It offers a comfortable ride and good fuel economy, but its interior isn't as durable or versatile as the Element's.
- Nissan Xterra: The Xterra is a more rugged SUV with a focus on off-road capability. It's not as fuel-efficient or refined as the Element, but it's a good choice for those who need a capable off-roader.
- Kia Soul: The Kia Soul is a quirky hatchback with a similar boxy shape to the Element. It's more fuel-efficient and affordable, but it lacks the Element's cargo capacity and durability.
Is a Used Honda Element a Good Choice for You?
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to buy a used Honda Element depends on your individual needs and priorities.
Consider the Element if:
- You need a versatile vehicle for hauling cargo, pets, or outdoor gear.
- You value durability and reliability over luxury and refinement.
- You appreciate the easy-clean interior and unique features.
- You're looking for an affordable and dependable used car.
Reconsider the Element if:
- You prioritize fuel economy and a comfortable ride.
- You need a vehicle with a lot of modern features.
- You're concerned about wind noise and handling.
- You live in an area with harsh winters and are worried about rust.
Frequently Asked Questions
- How long do Honda Elements typically last? With proper maintenance, Honda Elements can easily last for 200,000 miles or more. Many owners have reported reaching 300,000 miles and beyond.
- Are Honda Element parts expensive? Most common Honda parts are relatively affordable. However, some Element-specific parts can be more difficult to find and more expensive.
- Is the Honda Element good in snow? The four-wheel-drive Element is capable in snow. However, it's important to use appropriate tires for winter conditions.
- What's the average price of a used Honda Element? The price of a used Honda Element varies depending on its condition, mileage, and location. Expect to pay anywhere from ,000 to ,000.
- What are the best years for the Honda Element? The 2007-2011 models are generally considered the best, as they feature improved safety features and a more powerful engine.
The Final Verdict
The Honda Element is a unique and versatile vehicle that's earned a dedicated following. While it has its drawbacks, its practicality, durability, and unique features make it a compelling choice for the right buyer. Weigh the pros and cons carefully, and if it aligns with your needs, the Element could be the perfect vehicle for you.